Kirk Herbstreit leaves Amazon viewers stunned with peculiar 4-word TNF remark
Kirk Herbstreit leaves Amazon viewers stunned with peculiar 4-word TNF remark
Tom MalleySat, October 3, 2026 at 12:20 PM UTC
0
Kirk Herbstreit turned heads with something he said during Thursday's TNF broadcast of Cleveland vs. Pittsburgh -Credit:Getty Images
Kirk Herbstreit left fans stunned when opting to call out Cleveland's shortcomings during Thursday's game with the Pittsburgh Steelers as "Browns-on-Browns crime."
The 57-year-old was conducting his usual Thursday Night Football duties, which sees him serve as the primary NFL game analyst for Amazon Prime Video's exclusive broadcasts alongside legendary play-by-play announcer Al Michaels, for the Huntington Bank Field matchup — won by the Browns 27-24 — when he made the comment.
Midway through the first quarter, the Steelers faced a third-and-16, and though they fell well short of the first down, the Browns' defense committed three penalties on a single play, including a roughing-the-passer call on defensive tackle Maliek Collins.
• Aaron Rodgers immediately put down by Steelers coach after vulgar on-field tantrum
• Fed-up Aaron Rodgers completely ignores Steelers teammate in awkward sideline moment
Reacting to the chaotic lack of discipline, Herbstreit invoked a phrase used by Todd Monken earlier in the week about how Cleveland needed to stop beating themselves, when the Browns head coach said: "We're going to be a damn good football team once Browns stop hurting Browns."
Herbstreit, however, said things slightly differently.
Advertisement
"Three on one play! How symbolic is that for these first four weeks of the season for Todd Monken. He just talked about how you gotta quit having Browns-on-Browns crime," Herbstreit said.
While Herbstreit said nothing wrong, his use of phrasing certainly raised more than a few eyebrows. The ESPN College GameDay star quickly clarified that the term wasn't his own; he was directly quoting Monken, but the moment still got plenty of people talking online.
"Kirk Herbstreit calling Cleveland’s penalty issues 'Browns on Browns crime' is insane," one account posted to X.
"I don't think Kirk Herbstreit should've said that," wrote another, while a third person added: "Wild comment from him lol."
Others, though, were quick to stick up for Herbstreit, having recognized that it was just an unfortunate turn of phrase and that he was repeating what Monken had said earlier in the week, with one person writing: "That is a real stretch to try and find something wrong."
Herbstreit and Michaels also came under fire for their dismissal of Cleveland quarterback Deshaun Watson's off-field troubles -Credit:Frank Jansky/Icon Sportswire via Getty Images
Herbstreit actually received more flak for how he and Michaels handled the broader narrative surrounding Cleveland quarterback Deshaun Watson during the game, following his off-field controversies.
Fans called their commentary "cringeworthy" and "simplistic" after Michaels brushed aside Watson's extensive off-field legal history by saying "we don't have to go through the whole Deshaun Watson thing," while Herbstreit suggested that converting third downs and winning games would naturally make the home crowd's boos go away.
"You want the fans to get behind you, and that goes for pretty much any market," Herbstreit said. "This is an extreme case because of what you laid out with Deshaun Watson, but if you convert on third downs, you hit passes, you lead this team to victories, those boos turn into cheers."
Source: “AOL Sports”
